| Epic |
Romance | |
| heroic age | chivalric age | ![]() |
| weight, solidity | mystery, fantasy | |
| tragic, serious | light-hearted | |
| narrative unity | loose structure | |
| love is absent | love is supreme | |
| characters speak for themselves | narrative voice | |
| oral | literate | |
| didactic | subversive | |
Yvain enters the battle between the dragon and the lion. -- Chretien de Troyes |
||
From a Handbook of Literature
(a general, vague definition)
A tale of adventure in which knights, kings, or distressed ladies, motivated
by love, religious faith, or the mere desire for adventure, are the chief figures.
The medieval romance appears in Old French literature of the twelfth century
[…]. The epic reflects an heroic age, whereas the romance reflects a chivalric;
the epic has weight and solidity, whereas the romance exhibits mystery and fantasy;
the tragic seriousness or the epic is not matched in the lighter-hearted romance;
the epic observes narrative unity, whereas the structure of the romance is loose;
love, usually absent or of minor interest in the epic, is supreme in the romance;
the epic uses dramatic method of having the characters speak for themselves,
whereas the reader of the a romance remains conscious of a narrator. (Harmon)
Some Observations (Notice the contradictions.)
Audience
The audience for these early vernacular narratives was largely made up of women--the
queen, duchess or countess and the other ladies of her court. These women naturally
tended to be interested in stories in which women played more central roles
than was true in Germanic epics such as Beowulf (which centered almost exclusively
on the exploits of male warriors). Because the vernacular language poet's livelihood
depended upon pleasing his/her audience, the vernacular narratives written for
these courts ("romances") tended to focus on other plot developments
than the fighting and male-bonding emphasized in epic poetry. The narratives
still concern the deeds of brave warriors, but the Middle English knight (unlike
the Old English thane) is motivated by love for his lady. Accordingly, women
play an increasingly important and active role. –Deborah B. Schwartz
Adultery and Subversion
But the substitution of one form of control for another rent the fabric of feudal
society. A courtly lover, bound to his lord by ties of homage and duty, found
himself bound to an even further degree to the lord's lady. Feudal loyalty was
split into different and sometimes opposing obligations.
Courtly love, whose beginnings lay in the social control of the culturally disruptive sexual urge, became an immensely powerful movement under the leadership of Eleanor of Aquitaine. As Patricia Terry says, "... courtly poets raised love to the same important level as religion and warfare within the realm of poetry. Ecclesiastical poets had celebrated the fidelity of saints and martyrs. [...]!" (x-xi) The idea saturated Provençal culture, but failed, ultimately; to do the very thing it first set out to do reduce the friction and dissension that love caused to the feudal system. Courtly love defied the social order by making love more important than politics or religion.--Robert V. Graybill
The Role of Romance
Perhaps surprisingly, any "love interest" is likely to be incidental
to the story of a medieval romance. An exception to this rule may be found in
the breton lai: the term refers both to the relatively brief
form of medieval French romances, professed to have been sung by Breton minstrels
on Celtic themes, and to the English medieval poems written in imitation of
such works. These romances often wove their stories around a famous legendary
figure (Arthur, for example, or Tristram) and took as their immediate subject
matter a love story of some kind. –Jonathan A. Glenn
Characteristics of the Medieval
Romance
A tale of High Adventure. Can be a religious crusade, a conquest for the knight's
leige lord, or the rescue of a captive lady or any combination.
Characterized by:
1. Medieval romance usually idealizes chivalry
2. Medieval romance Idealizes the hero-knight and his noble deeds
3. An important element of the medieval romance is the knight's love for his
lady.
4. The settings of medieval romance tend to be imaginary and vague.
5. Medieval romance derives mystery and suspense from supernatural elements.
6. Medieval romance uses concealed or disguised identity.
7. Repetition of the mystical number "3." (Repetitions of the number
or multiples of 3)
-- http://www.loyno.edu/~MidAges/